Friday, December 15, 2023
Reviews

Quiet Dust Collector

Keeping your workshop clean can be a pain, but it’s important for safety and productivity. And let’s be real, nobody wants to work in a dusty mess. Lucky for us, there’s a solution: a dust collector. This handy machine sucks up all the crap from your workspace, filters out the dust particles, and blows out clean air.

But here’s the catch, the problem is that workshop machinery is SUPER noisy! These things are loud as hell and can make you lose your mind. Too much noise is not only annoying, but it may also reduce your productivity and possibly cause hearing damage. Fortunately, manufacturers are now producing dust collectors that are as effective as traditional versions while being silent. So now you can work in peace and have a clean workshop without the headache. Check out our article for all the deets on the best quiet dust collectors out there!

My NEW Affordable More Powerful Wen Dust Collector. 0 4 screenshot 1 Quiet Dust Collector

Benefits of a Dust Collection System

Before we start, you have to know why dust collection systems are works of wonders. For starters, when the air is contaminated with dirt, dust, debris, chemicals, or gasses, it can harm the lungs of anybody who inhales it. Additionally, this particle can gather on or near equipment, creating a serious fire risk.

These pollutants are collected from the air by a dust collector, which cleans the air and improves the safety of everyone inside.

Likewise, dirt, dust, and debris that build on equipment might make their way inside, interfering with the device’s mechanics. This can result in slower machinery and equipment failure. Machines that have been compromised require constant care and repairs. Dust collectors eliminate this danger, enabling your machinery to function at its best.

Understanding the Two Main Types of Dust Collectors

A dust collector is a machine designed to remove dust, debris, and other particles from the air in a woodworking or metalworking shop. They are designed to keep the air in the shop clean and safe to breathe, while also protecting the machinery and equipment from damage caused by dust buildup. The dust collector works by drawing air and dust through a series of filters and capturing the dust in a collection bin or bag. A quiet dust collector is ideal for use in smaller shops or areas where noise is a concern, as they are designed to operate at a lower noise level than traditional dust collectors.

Dust collectors are usually distinguished in single-stage or two-stage systems with different configurations but comparable components, here’s how they differ:

1. Single-Stage Dust Collectors

Before falling into a lower bag or container, wood particles and dust pass via the impeller. As the air escapes through the cloth filter bag and back into the workstation, the dust is collected in an upper bag. The top bag collapses when the device is turned off, and much of the dust falls into the collector.

Larger particles can harm or jam the impeller, causing damage, while smaller particles can get into bearings and other moving components, causing damage. Plastic, nylon, or metal impeller blades are the most common in the market.

2. Two-Stage Dust Collectors

A two-stage collector has two sections and is set up differently. The coarse dust is initially drawn to the top of a barrel or container, where it is sucked out of the suction stream and collected in a collection bin. The finer particles are pulled up into the impeller and out into the cloth filter bag in the following stage.

After the impeller is in the after-stage, the air filters through the cloth and returns to the shop, the bag gathers the tiny dust. Larger particles getting collected or making their way into the filter bag are less likely to clog an after-stage filter and impeller. The two-stage unit has better suction and returns cleaner air.

Features to Look for While Choosing a Dust Collector

Testing CHEAP VS EXPENSIVE Dust Collection Systems 0 5 screenshot 1 1 Quiet Dust Collector

There are several factors to consider while purchasing a dust collector. The collector’s type and size, as well as its noise rating, shop size, airflow velocity, and bag or canister type, are just a few of the collector characteristics to consider. Specifically, here’s a wind-up list of the things you should look out for when buying a quiet garbage collector:

Dust storage capacity: Choose a dust collector with a sufficient dust storage capacity to avoid having to empty it too frequently. This is especially important if you work with large volumes of dust and debris.

Dust storage capacity:8. Storage type: Bag or CanisterBoth the bag and the canister are superior to a shop vac. The larger surface area of the canister traps more dirt and finer particles. The bag has a micron rating of 1 to 35 and is sensitive to puncture or damage by wood or metal objects. The canister is puncture-proof and may be equipped with a 1-micron pleated filter.

1. Noise Level Dust collectors should be between 60 and 70 decibels quiet. The longer you are exposed to equipment that is louder over 80dB, the more likely you are to get hearing loss. You have hearing damage if you feel a ringing in your ears after using a dust collector and power equipment. Choose a collector with the lowest STC rating possible, so you’ll get a quiet appliance based on its soundproofing material capabilities.
2. Sones and CFM CFM stands for cubic feet per minute and is the measuring unit for expelling airflow. When using a dust collector, the higher the CFM number, the more air is exhausted.
On the other hand, sone is a globally accepted loudness measuring unit that can accurately predict what humans can hear. When the number of sones in noise is doubled, the volume of the sound is likewise doubled (more info about sones on vedantu.com).
3. Size The number of tools you have depends on the size of your workshop, which may help you decide if a dust collector that can handle several machines is the best match. A medium-sized or industrial dust collector that can be mounted to many tools at once is a suitable fit for workshops with several pieces of fixed equipment.
Of course, larger dust collector models will take up more room on your shop floor, which is another consideration to consider when choosing a model.
4. Weight and Portability Lightweight dust collectors, in general, are preferable for workshops that use a lot of handheld instruments, such as orbit sanders and belt sanders, to name a few. Fixed medium-sized or industrial dust collectors, on the other hand, are tough workhorses that match your workshop’s mainstays, such as planers and table saws.
5. Motor and Horsepower One way to determine the dust collector’s airflow rate is to look at its air suction capacity. The unit’s airflow is commonly measured in cubic feet per minute, or CFM- as we said earlier, which also shows how strong the motor is.
Portable versions can have a CFM rate of approximately 150 CFM, whereas industrial ones can have a CFM rate of 1,500 CFM or even more. Heavy motors rated at 1 horsepower or even 2 horsepower or more are common in industrial models.
6. Filtration System The dust collector’s filtration capacity affects how well it removes suspended dust particles from the air. Most manufacturers specify a minimum dust particle diameter that their filters can collect – typical airbag filters should screen dust particles with a diameter of 2.5 microns or less.
HEPA filters are used by several dust collector manufacturers. HEPA stands for high-efficiency particulate air. Pollen, pet dander, and even smoke are typically believed to be trapped by these filters (read more about HEPA filters on smartairfilters.com).
7. Dust storage capacity Choose a dust collector with a sufficient dust storage capacity to avoid having to empty it too frequently. This is especially important if you work with large volumes of dust and debris.

Dust Collector’s Storage Types

  1. Cyclone dust collectors: These collectors use centrifugal force to separate dust and debris from the air stream. They are highly efficient and can handle large volumes of air.
  2. Baghouse dust collectors: These collectors use fabric bags to filter out dust and debris from the air stream. They are ideal for fine dust particles and are commonly used in industries such as cement, pharmaceuticals, and food processing.
  3. Cartridge dust collectors: These collectors use pleated filter cartridges to capture dust and debris. They are highly efficient and can handle a wide range of particle sizes.
  4. Wet scrubbers: These collectors use water to capture dust and debris from the air stream. They are ideal for capturing large particles and are commonly used in industries such as mining and metalworking.
  5. Electrostatic precipitators: These collectors use an electrical charge to attract and capture dust particles. They are highly efficient and can handle a wide range of particle sizes.

When choosing a dust collector, it is important to consider the type of dust or debris you are trying to capture, the volume of air that needs to be filtered, and the size of the space where the collector will be used.

Video: 5 Common Mistakes When Selecting a Dust Collector

FAQ

Are dust collectors noisy?

Dust collectors have the drawback of being quite loud. There are a variety of reasons why you would wish to take efforts to decrease the noise, especially when they operate constantly for lengthy periods of time. The first reason is for your employees’ safety and comfort. That’s why the quiet collectors we mentioned above would be a great help in keeping your peace and quiet!

How to quiet down a dust collector?

Because dust collectors frequently fit neatly into corners, a two-sided enclosure is a good place to start. You may make your enclosure permanent or create a standalone, detachable solution by attaching two wall panels together. Further noise reduction can be achieved by lining the inside of the enclosure with a stiff foam board or “egg-crate” acoustic foam.

How do quiet dust collectors work?

 Quiet dust collectors work by using a powerful fan to draw dust and debris into a collection chamber, where it is filtered and removed. The difference is that they are designed with noise reduction features, such as insulated cabinets and quieter motors, to minimize noise levels during operation.

Is a dust collector quieter than a shop vac?

Dust collectors are typically quieter than shop vacs, can contain more chips, and can accommodate a longer hose. A shop-vac, on the other hand, is better than nothing for dust collection on nearly any fixed power equipment. A dust collector, though, would be unsuitable and ineffective for most handheld equipment.

Is a dust collector quieter than a shop vac?

Dust collectors are typically quieter than shop vacs, can contain more chips, and can accommodate a longer hose. A shop-vac, on the other hand, is better than nothing for dust collection on nearly any fixed power equipment. A dust collector, though, would be unsuitable and ineffective for most handheld equipment.

How do I maintain my quiet dust collector?

To keep your quiet dust collector running smoothly, be sure to regularly clean or replace the filters as needed. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for maintenance and cleaning, and be sure to schedule regular inspections and servicing as necessary.

So, What Is the Best Quiet Dust Collector for You?

WEN 3401 5.7-Amp 660 CFM Dust Collector with 12-Gallon Bag and Optional...
SHOP FOX Portable W1727 1 HP Dust Collector
WEN 3410 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System (300/350/400 CFM),...
JET DC-1100VX-CK Vortex Cone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Canister Filter, 1100...
CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17595 16 Gallon 6.5 Peak HP Wet/Dry Vac, Heavy-Duty Shop...
JET JCDC-3 Cyclone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Filter, 1240 CFM, 3HP, 1Ph 230...
5.7-amp brushed motor. 660 CFM. 4-inch dust port. 12-gallon zippered collection bag. Four 1-3/4 inch swivel casters.
Meets Underwriters Laboratories (UL) and Canadian Standards Association (CSA) safety standards. 800 CFM. 2.5 Micron Filtration.
Includes a 1-micron filter and a 5-micron pre-filter. Programmable timer. RF remote system. Easy-to-use remote control..
Vortex cone. Quick-connect collection bags. High air velocity design. Permanently-lubricated, totally-inclosed, fan-cooled motors. Includes 4 casters..
Heavy-duty. Built-in blower port. Built-in oversized drain. Dual-Flex technology for 180-degree mobility.
Constant suction. Double-paddle manual cleaning system. Canister filter captures 99% of 2-micron perticles. Radio frequensy remote control.
Best Сost-Effective
WEN 3401 5.7-Amp 660 CFM Dust Collector with 12-Gallon Bag and Optional...
5.7-amp brushed motor. 660 CFM. 4-inch dust port. 12-gallon zippered collection bag. Four 1-3/4 inch swivel casters.
Best Portable
SHOP FOX Portable W1727 1 HP Dust Collector
Meets Underwriters Laboratories (UL) and Canadian Standards Association (CSA) safety standards. 800 CFM. 2.5 Micron Filtration.
Best Air Filtration
WEN 3410 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System (300/350/400 CFM),...
Includes a 1-micron filter and a 5-micron pre-filter. Programmable timer. RF remote system. Easy-to-use remote control..
Best Efficiency
JET DC-1100VX-CK Vortex Cone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Canister Filter, 1100...
Vortex cone. Quick-connect collection bags. High air velocity design. Permanently-lubricated, totally-inclosed, fan-cooled motors. Includes 4 casters..
Best Versatile
CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17595 16 Gallon 6.5 Peak HP Wet/Dry Vac, Heavy-Duty Shop...
Heavy-duty. Built-in blower port. Built-in oversized drain. Dual-Flex technology for 180-degree mobility.
Best Cyclone Dust Collector
JET JCDC-3 Cyclone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Filter, 1240 CFM, 3HP, 1Ph 230...
Constant suction. Double-paddle manual cleaning system. Canister filter captures 99% of 2-micron perticles. Radio frequensy remote control.

1. WEN 3401 Dust Collector – Best Сost-Effective

WEN 3401 5.7-Amp 660 CFM Dust Collector with 12-Gallon Bag and Optional...
WEN 3401 5.7-Amp 660 CFM Dust Collector with 12-Gallon Bag and Optional...
  • 5.7-amp brushed motor combined with the 6-inch impeller moves over 660 cubic feet of air per...
  • 4-inch dust port allows for connection to your favorite woodworking tools
If you’re in great need of a dust collector but your budget won’t allow it, just relax and close your eyes, and buy this dust collector instead, if it, of course, serves your purpose. This device is extremely compact, making it easy to store and travel. It’s good, and you wouldn’t have to pay more than $100 for it.

Optimum Horsepower

With a 5.7-amp motor, the WEN 12-gallon Dust Collector moves over 660 cubic feet of air per minute. You may connect your favorite woodworking equipment to the 6-inch impeller and 4-inch dust port inlet.

Lightweight and Portable

The four 1-3/4 inch swivel casters of this product lock into place to prevent unwanted movement, and the compact design makes storage and transportation between jobs a breeze! Remove the wheels and use the optional built-in wall mount to attach it to your shop’s wall for convenient dust collecting anytime you need it.

Overall

With this device, the air in the immediate vicinity of the workplace is immediately cleaned. The issue is that it can be a little noisier than its competitors. However, if you can get beyond that one flaw and enjoy the other advantages that this device offers, this may be the perfect tool for you (more info on Dustcollectorgeeks.com).

Video: WEN 3401 Dust Collector – 1 Year Later Review!

2. SHOP FOX W1727 1 HP Dust Collector – Best Portable

Sale
SHOP FOX Portable W1727 1 HP Dust Collector
SHOP FOX Portable W1727 1 HP Dust Collector
  • Motor: 1 HP, 120V/240V, single-phase, prewired 110V
  • Motor amp draw: 9A/4.5A
This device from Shopfox is one of the best dust collectors for anyone looking for a portable dust handling system. Because it was intended for portability, it can be moved from one machine to another as needed, rather than having to construct a set dust collecting system and run ducts to each unit.

Versatile for Multi-Machine Support

The Shop Fox W1727’s seamless compatibility with many common machines is one of the reasons it’s a favorite among workshop owners. When you combine the tool’s high mobility with its ability to handle a wide range of machines, you have a dust collector that you can rely on even when the workshop is at full capacity.

Compact with High-Quality Components

At first look, this system appears to be compact. And that’s a good thing because the complete equipment fits without being obtrusive in a small shop. Even if space isn’t an issue, no business owner wants large-signature instruments, especially if they’re only used for a specific purpose. You can rely on the W1727 to make the most of your space!

Overall

This dust collector is ideal for small businesses. So, if you want to clean up your shop, purchase the Shop Fox W1727—1 HP 800 CFM dust collector and be amazed at how much better your workstation will look. The best part is that it may be used as a stationary central dust collector or as a mobile dust collector (check on Homedepot.com).

Video: Shop Fox Dust Collector Review

3. WEN 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System – Best Air Filtration System

WEN 3410 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System (300/350/400 CFM),...
WEN 3410 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System (300/350/400 CFM),...
  • Includes a 1-micron filter and a 5-micron pre-filter, both of which can be easily replaced
  • Dimensions – 17” L x 20.5” W x 10” H | Electrical Requirements – 120V, 60 Hz, 1A |...
Woodworking is a delightful activity. However, if you work in a poorly ventilated workshop, things may get a little stressful. You must guarantee that any sawdust-related dust is removed from the room. The WEN 3410 Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System is the best shop air filtration system you can trust for this task.

Great User Interface

The included remote allows you to manage the quiet system from up to 26 feet away. The lightweight design also comes with hooks for simple installation to any ceiling and weighs only 31 pounds! Depending on the situation, you may even easily choose between three settings of 300, 350, and 400 CFM.

Time Function

You won’t ever have to worry about forgetting to switch off your machine if you use the time function. All you have to do is set the timer. When the timer runs out, the machine will switch off on its own, allowing you to clean your workshop thoroughly at the end of a day of woodworking without needing to actually be there.

Overall

Overall, this machine is the most reliable air filtering system available. It not only circulates clean air around the room, but it also kills bacteria in the air. It’s a strong machine with two dust-trapping filters. And, it runs quietly and maybe simply operated using a remote control (check on Homedepot.com).

Video: Wen 3410 Air Filter – 3 Year Review on the 3-Speed Remote-Controlled Air Filtration System

4. Jet DC-1100VX-CK 1.5-HP Dust Collector – Best Efficiency

Sale
JET DC-1100VX-CK Vortex Cone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Canister Filter, 1100...
JET DC-1100VX-CK Vortex Cone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Canister Filter, 1100...
  • Rated for Continuous Duty: Permanently lubricated, totally enclosed, fan-cooled motors.
  • Fast Installation and Removal: Quick-connect collection bags with elastic band.
The Jet DC-1100VX-CK Dust Collector (official website) has Vortex Cone Technology and a 2-micron canister kit. This allows it to work efficiently by avoiding clogging and dividing chips, allowing them to fall out more easily into the collecting bag. It includes an enclosed 1.5 HP, 1-phase motor that enhances the product’s efficiency, and the steel impeller maximizes air intake.

Maximum Filtration Efficiency

The dust collector by Jet has an 1100 CFM airflow for optimum filtering efficiency, and four casters are incorporated for portability and mobility. The filters are rotated to guarantee that the dust gathered is not accumulated, causing any harm to the user.

The Effective and Quiet Air Filtration System

This product performs excellently, filtering out 98 percent of 2-micron particles and 86 percent of 1-micron particles for cleaner, more breathable air. It has a sound rating of 70 to 80 dB and comes with a 5-year defect repair guarantee from Jet, which includes free repair services.

Overall

Jet’s DC-1100VX-CK Dust Collector is carefully designed with the goal of increasing efficiency and providing superior performance to its customers. This fantastic machine is a must-have for all serious woodworkers, whether you operate a little business or a large one! (check on Homedepot.com)

Video: JET 708659K DC-1100VX Dust Collector- Assembly and Set-Up

5. CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17595 Wet/Dry Vac – Best Versatile

Sale
CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17595 16 Gallon 6.5 Peak HP Wet/Dry Vac, Heavy-Duty Shop...
CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17595 16 Gallon 6.5 Peak HP Wet/Dry Vac, Heavy-Duty Shop...
  • HEAVY-DUTY: Powerful 6.5 Peak HP provides extra power for large projects in the garage, shop...
  • BUILT-IN BLOWER PORT: Rear blowing port on this wet dry vac allows for quick cleaning of leaves...
This heavy-duty vacuum (official website) is perfect for large jobs and would be equally at home in the garage as on the job site. When you need to get the work done with a lot of power and drive, this is the equipment to use. It has a 6.5 HP motor, plus, it has wet and dry nozzles, making it ideal for both wet and dry cleanups.

Convenient to Use

This is a great option for those who are concerned about storage space, since one of the most decent features of this vacuum is that it has built-in hose storage as well as power cord organizers, making it a much more efficient and streamlined model. It’s also remarkably quiet when compared to many other shop vacs on the market!

Cost-Effective

The fact that this device can be purchased for a little under $100 makes it an excellent entry-level option for people on a limited budget. The rear blowing port and huge drain make this multi-functional and extremely appealing for all types of commercial items, making it one of Craftsman’s greatest products.

Overall

This heavy-duty wet-dry vacuum will provide you with high performance. It comes with a built-in blower port as well as an oversized drain. A flex hose, two extension wands, a utility nozzle, a vehicle nozzle, a wet nozzle, a filter, and dust collecting bag are included as accessories, talk about being versatile! (check on Walmart.com)

Video: Craftsman 16 Gallon Wet/Dry Shop Vac – Quick Unboxing and Review

6. Jet JCDC-3 Cyclone Dust Collector – Best Cyclone Dust Collector

Sale
JET JCDC-3 Cyclone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Filter, 1240 CFM, 3HP, 1Ph 230...
JET JCDC-3 Cyclone Dust Collector, 2-Micron Filter, 1240 CFM, 3HP, 1Ph 230...
  • CONSTANT SUCTION: Heavy debris is pulled down to collection drum before debris stream reaches...
  • QUICK-RELEASE COLLECTION DRUM: Heavy debris is captured in a 66-gallon drum.
Jet remains the most popular brand of Cyclone Dust Collectors and for good reason. The Jet JCDC-1.5 1.5 HP option (official website) is one of her most popular models. The top-of-the-line model has a 1.5 horsepower engine that offers strong performance to keep your woodshop cleaner than before.

Impressive CFM Power

When compared to single-stage dust collectors with equivalent horsepower, this machine delivers at a 2-stage unit, which provides more CFM of airflow. As a result, anticipate this collector’s 763 CFM to suck more particles in less time than typical collectors of the same rating.

Big Barrel

A large 20-gallon barrel holds the large and heavy trash in this unit. Although this capacity is adequate for certain businesses, it is insufficient for those with machines that generate a significant amount of dust. The filter’s pleated layer catches dust particles as tiny as one micron.

Overall

Among the features we mentioned above, quick-release levers are also included with the dust drum. This feature, along with the unit’s smooth-rolling wheels, makes emptying a breeze. Even with the dust drum full, the swivel casters make moving the extractor about your business a breeze. A high-quality radio frequency remote control is also included with the unit (check on Homedepot.com).

Video: JET Cyclone Dust Collectors Overview

Conclusion

It is vital to evaluate your requirements before acquiring a dust collector. In layman’s terms, your dust collector needs to have the most suctioning power of all your machines, among other things. Even if you do not already have this equipment, investing in a more powerful dust collector will ensure that you do not face any difficulties when you do. We hope that now that you’ve read this article, you won’t have to put up with a loud workplace anymore!

Video: 11 common workshop dust collection mistakes

Flick Emil Henricus

I'm a 34-year-old freelance musician and soundproofing specialist, DIY enthusiast, blog author, and Silence Wiki founder originally from the Netherlands. I've been a musician for over 15 years now - playing all sorts of instruments but especially guitar and saxophone. As a soundproofing specialist, I help people with their acoustic needs in order to make them happy! I also enjoy DIY projects around the house or wherever else they are needed - thanks to my wife who always has great ideas!